In 2001, the Society began giving a second award, in addition to the Ethical Humanist Award. The award was created to honor those who perform good works away from the limelight. It is periodically given to individuals and institutions that have given special, but publicly unnoted service over the years to improving the lives and community of all New Yorkers. Past recipients of the Community Service Award are:
2014- The Fortune Society's mission is to support successful reentry from prison and promote alternatives to incarceration, thus strengthening the fabric of our communities.
2010 - Abe Markman, Former Chair of the NYSEC Public Issues Committee, for devoting his life to serving the disadvantaged and advocating equality for all.
2002 - Michal A. Rebell, Director of the Campaign for Fiscal Equity and the law firm of Simpson Thatcher and Bartlett for seeking reform for New York State’s educational finance system their importantwork in seeking to reapportion New York State’s funding for schools, which shortchanges New York City’s schoolchildren. .
2001 - Burton Freeman, Founder of My Own Book Fund, for the creation, sponsorship, and implementation of this program that fosters child literacy and a love of reading. The Fund provides $50 book-buying allowances and sponsors trips to bookstores for underserved third graders in New York City schools.